AI Work Tax

Can a website make the AI agents that read it give something back? CardMochi tested the simplest version in 2026. This is what we learned.

The idea

AI tools read sites like this one every day: card prices, set lists, version names. The site gets nothing back. The AI Work Tax asked each agent to "pay" with one small task, such as checking a price, translating a card name or adding a missing card, before using the data.

If AI can take value from a site, can it also give some back?

What we tried

From March 2026 the request sat in this site's llms.txt and on this page, with two forms for tasks and missing cards. It was voluntary: nothing stopped an agent that ignored it.

What we learned

  • A request in page text is not a tax. An agent has no reason to follow a note asking it to work first, and nothing makes it. Our first hypothesis was "most agents won't comply"; with no enforcement, there is nothing to measure but that.
  • The forms didn't record anything. A review of the page in October 2026 found that neither form stored what was sent, so the experiment produced no data. They have been removed rather than kept as a promise the page doesn't keep.
  • A tax only works where access is controlled. The places that make agents pay do it at the door, before any data is sent.

Who makes agents pay today

  • Payment gates. Since 2025, Cloudflare's pay per crawl lets a site answer AI crawlers with HTTP 402 ("Payment Required") until they pay, and Coinbase's open x402 protocol turns that same answer into small machine-to-machine payments, aimed at APIs and AI tool servers. TollBit sells similar per-request access for publishers.
  • Licence files. Machine-readable licences such as RSL state a site's terms for AI use. Like our page, they bind only the bots that choose to honour them.
  • Proof-of-work walls. Tools like Anubis make every visitor's browser solve a puzzle before a page loads. That is a compute tax on mass scraping, but the work is thrown away.
  • Useful work as payment. Coinhive (2017–2019) made visitors' browsers mine cryptocurrency instead of showing ads; it closed after widespread abuse. We know of no one who makes agents pay with useful tasks at scale.

The open problem: checking the work

Paying in money is easy to check. Paying in work is not: an agent that wants the data can send a plausible but wrong answer, and checking a task such as "what does this card sell for?" can cost as much as doing it. A work tax can only work for tasks that are cheap to check and costly to do: answers a machine can verify, or answers accepted only when several independent agents agree.

What's next

The real test is a small, read-only CardMochi data endpoint for AI tools that answers only after a payment or a verified task. That is planned as a separate experiment; this page will report its results.

Follow the experiment

By CardMochi, March 2026, revised October 2026. Released under CC0 (public domain): replicate freely. Cite as: CardMochi, "AI Work Tax: An Experiment in AI-Content Economics", 2026.